GHSA-cpgf-5mjf-73p7: rails-html-sanitizer: Possible regular expression denial of service with certain configurations
Summary
Rails::HTML::PermitScrubber restricts the href and xlink:href attributes of SVG reference elements to local references. That check matched the attribute value against /^\s[^#\s]./m. In Ruby ^ anchors to every line start and \s matches newlines, so an all-whitespace value made the engine rescan the value from each of its line starts, taking time quadratic in its length.
- Versions affected: >= 1.0.3, < 1.7.2 - Not affected: < 1.0.3 - Fixed versions: 1.7.2
Only Ruby 3.1 and earlier are affected. Ruby 3.2 added linear-time regexp matching, which makes the pattern linear.
Impact
An attacker who supplies HTML to be sanitized can consume CPU out of proportion to the input size, by sending an SVG reference element whose href or xlink:href is a long run of whitespace.
Applications are affected only when the allowed tags are overridden to include an SVG reference element such as use, along with href or xlink:href in the allowed attributes. The default allowed tags include no SVG elements, so the default configuration is not affected. Applications that use Loofah directly are exposed through its own copy of the check, fixed in Loofah 2.25.3.
Workarounds
Run Ruby 3.2 or later, which matches the pattern in linear time, or remove the SVG reference elements from the overridden allowed tags.
Credit
Reported by scyoon through the Rails HackerOne program.
Affected Software
Remediation
Recommended actions to resolve this vulnerability, in priority order.
- Upgrade
Upgrade
rubygems/rails-html-sanitizerto a version that resolves this vulnerability.Fixed in 1.7.2 - Upgrade
Upgrade to a fixed release to a version that resolves this vulnerability.
Fixed in 1.7.2 - Upgrade
Upgrade to a fixed release to a version that resolves this vulnerability.
Fixed in 2.25.3 - Upgrade
Upgrade to a fixed release to a version that resolves this vulnerability.
Fixed in 3.2 - Configuration
Remove SVG reference elements from the overridden allowed tags.
Rails::HTML::PermitScrubber allowed tags = Exclude SVG reference elements such as `use`
Event History
Frequently Asked Questions
Which deployments are actually exposed?
Exposure requires a customized allowlist that permits an SVG reference element such as use and also permits href or xlink:href. The default allowed-tag configuration contains no SVG elements and is not affected.
What must an attacker provide to trigger the issue?
An attacker must be able to supply HTML that the application sanitizes. They can consume disproportionate CPU by using an SVG reference element with an href or xlink:href value consisting of a long run of whitespace.
Does the Ruby runtime version affect exploitability?
Only Ruby 3.1 and earlier are affected by the quadratic regular-expression behavior. Ruby 3.2 performs this regular-expression matching in linear time.
What versions address the issue?
Upgrade rails-html-sanitizer to version 1.7.2. Versions earlier than 1.0.3 are not affected; the affected range is 1.0.3 through versions before 1.7.2.
What should teams using Loofah directly do?
Loofah has its own copy of the affected check when used directly. Upgrade Loofah to version 2.25.3, where that check is fixed.