See how modoboa compares to other vendors in security performance
Cross-site Scripting (XSS) - DOM in GitHub repository modoboa/modoboa prior to 2.2.2.
Authentication Bypass by Primary Weakness in GitHub repository modoboa/modoboa prior to 2.0.4.
Modoboa 2.0.5 and prior allows users to set unsafe passwords, such as 1 or HACK. This issue is fixed in commit 130257c96a2392ada795785a91178e656e27015c and is part of version 2.1.0.
Improper Authorization in GitHub repository modoboa/modoboa prior to 2.1.0.
Improper Authorization in GitHub repository modoboa/modoboa prior to 2.1.0.
Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) in GitHub repository modoboa/modoboa prior to 2.2.2.
Modoboa before 2.9.0 contains an insecure direct object reference vulnerability in the PUT /api/v1/accounts/{pk}/password/ endpoint that allows domain administrators to change any user's password. Attackers with domain admin privileges can bypass object-level access controls to reset superadmin passwords and achieve full account takeover.
The modoboa-dmarc plugin 1.1.0 for Modoboa is vulnerable to an XML External Entity Injection (XXE) attack when processing XML data. A remote attacker could exploit this to perform a denial of service against the DMARC reporting functionality, such as by referencing the /dev/random file within XML documents that are emailed to the address in the rua field of the DMARC records of a domain.
Improper Restriction of Excessive Authentication Attempts in GitHub repository modoboa/modoboa-installer prior to 2.0.4.
Summary
execcmd() in modoboa/lib/sysutils.py always runs subprocess calls with shell=True. Since domain names flow directly into shell command strings without any sanitization, a Reseller or SuperAdmin can include shell metacharacters in a domain name to run arbitrary OS commands on the server.
Details
The root cause is in modoboa/lib/sysutils.py:31:
python kwargs["shell"] = True process = subprocess.Popen(cmd, kwargs)
When a create a domain is created with DKIM enabled, the domain name gets embedded into a shell command like this:
python execcmd(f"openssl genrsa -out {dkimstoragedir}/{domain.name}.pem {keysize}")
If the domain name contains something like $(id>/tmp/proof).example.com, the shell executes the injected command before running openssl.
The same pattern appears in several other places:
- modoboa/admin/jobs.py:38 — mailbox rename via mv using fulladdress - modoboa/amavis/lib.py:202 — sa-learn using domain.name - modoboa/admin/models/mailbox.py:150 — doveadm user using fulladdress - modoboa/maillog/graphics.py:105–107 — rrdtool using domain.name - modoboa/webmail/models.py:54–57 — doveadm move/delete using account.email
PoC
1. Deploy modoboa <= 2.7.0 2. Log in as a Reseller or SuperAdmin 3. Create a new domain named $(id>/tmp/proof).example.com with DKIM enabled 4. SSH into the server and read /tmp/proof
Something like this will be displayed:
uid=0(root) gid=0(root) groups=0(root)
Confirmed on commit b521bcb4f (latest main at time of discovery).
Impact
An attacker with Reseller-level access (or higher) can execute arbitrary OS commands on the mail server — in a typical Modoboa deployment this means running as root. All six identified sinks are reachable through normal application workflows.
Cross-site Scripting (XSS) - Stored in GitHub repository modoboa/modoboa prior to 2.0.4.
Cross-site Scripting (XSS) - DOM in GitHub repository modoboa/modoboa prior to 2.2.2.
Cross-site Scripting (XSS) - Stored in GitHub repository modoboa/modoboa prior to 2.0.4.
Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) in GitHub repository modoboa/modoboa prior to 2.1.0.
Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) in GitHub repository modoboa/modoboa prior to 2.0.4.
Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) in GitHub repository modoboa/modoboa prior to 2.0.4.
Cross-site Scripting (XSS) - Stored in GitHub repository modoboa/modoboa prior to 2.0.4.
Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) in GitHub repository modoboa/modoboa prior to 2.0.4.
Modoboa before 2.8.0 contains an insecure direct object reference vulnerability that allows authenticated users to delete alarms of other domains via the POST /api/v2/alarms/bulkdelete/ action. Attackers can enumerate sequential alarm IDs to delete DNS, MX and blocklist monitoring alarms server-wide, hiding problems from responsible administrators.
Modoboa before 2.8.0 contains an insecure direct object reference vulnerability that allows authenticated users to create auto-reply messages for arbitrary mailboxes by supplying another user's mbox value. Attackers can POST to /api/v2/armessages/ to inject attacker-controlled auto-reply subject and content into victims' settings or break their auto-reply management via MultipleObjectsReturned errors.
Modoboa before 2.13.0 contains a CRLF injection vulnerability that allows Resellers or users with domain add or change permission to inject rspamd DKIM selector map entries by supplying an unvalidated dkimkeyselector through the relay domain API. Attackers can embed a carriage return in the selector to override another tenant's domain selector, causing rspamd to sign its outgoing mail with a nonexistent selector and fail DKIM verification.
Modoboa before 2.13.0 contains a CRLF injection vulnerability that allows Resellers or users with domain add or change permission to inject rspamd DKIM selector map entries by supplying an unvalidated dkimkeyselector through the relay domain API. Attackers can embed a carriage return in the selector to override another tenant's domain selector, causing rspamd to sign its outgoing mail with a nonexistent selector and fail DKIM verification.
Cross-site Scripting (XSS) - Reflected in GitHub repository modoboa/modoboa prior to 2.0.5.
Cross-site Scripting (XSS) - Reflected in GitHub repository modoboa/modoboa prior to 2.0.45.